Did Eliezer Yudkowsky Write The Erogamer?
Answer: Probably not. But there’s a twist.
Now that we’ve got the boring stuff out of the way, let’s get to the interesting parts. Why do people think Yudkowsky wrote The Erogamer ? I don’t know. I’ve never read The Erogamer Planecrash , you can see why that description would make people suspect Yudkowsky of being the author.
Why do I think Yudkowsky probably didn’t write The Erogamer ? Stylometry . You’ve probably heard of stylometry in the context of LLMs being able to determine the authors of texts . That’s what it is: determining who authored a piece of text
Now, I’ve mentioned Burrows’s Delta before, in my post on galaxy-brained explanations . Burrows’s Delta is a method that takes the $n$ most frequent words (MFWs), converts their raw frequencies in each text into standardized scores, then computes a distance between documents, which we can use to determine who wrote a text if, for example, we have sample texts whose authorship we already know (for more details, see the Appendix ). To add a bit of robustness and test sensitivity to this choice, I vary $n$, using comparison vectors made from the 100, 150, 200, 250, and 300 most frequent words.
I’ve gathered various works of fiction written by ratfic authors and Worm fanfic authors (because Groon the Walker previously wrote a Worm fic). Here are the documents that are closest to The Erogamer , with bold entries indicating reciprocity (The Erogamer is among that work’s five closest as well):
Rank
100 MFWs
150 MFWs
200 MFWs
250 MFWs
300 MFWs
1
DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species
DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species
DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species
2
Groon the Walker, Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist
Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Eliezer Yudkowsky, Planecrash / Project Lawful (Eliezer-attributed turns)
Groon the Walker, Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist
Groon the Walker, Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist
3
qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure
DaystarEld, Guardian DaystarEld, Guardian
Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm]
Eliezer Yudkowsky, Planecrash / Project Lawful (Eliezer-attributed turns)
4
BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin
Groon the Walker, Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist
Groon the Walker, Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist
Eliezer Yudkowsky, Planecrash / Project Lawful (Eliezer-attributed turns)
Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm]
5
Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm]
qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure
Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm]
DaystarEld, Guardian
DaystarEld, Guardian
So, it looks like our top candidate is not Yudkowsky but DaystarEld. But, being a rationalist, I can’t help wondering exactly how confident I should be that DaystarEld wrote The Erogamer . This is where Bayes comes into play. For each candidate author $a$, I’ve calculated $P(a\text{ is the true author} \mid C_a=c)$, where $C_a$ denotes the minimum rank attained by any work by $a$, and $c\in\lbrace1, 2\text{–}5, >5\rbrace$.
Dots show posterior means; error bars show 95% highest-density intervals. The dashed line marks the uniform 1/14 prior.
The probabilities below assume a uniform prior over the fourteen candidate authors. The five MFW settings are sensitivity checks rather than independent evidence, so I report them separately instead of combining them into a single posterior. The authors are ordered by their mean probability across the five settings.
Author
100 MFWs
150 MFWs
200 MFWs
250 MFWs
300 MFWs
1. DaystarEld
88.9%
94.1%
95.2%
94.7%
97.7%
2. Thearia
3.0%
1.3%
1.5%
1.3%
0.2%
3. qntm (Sam Hughes)
3.0%
1.3%
0.2%
1.3%
0.2%
4. Eliezer Yudkowsky
0.2%
1.3%
1.5%
1.3%
0.2%
5. BeaconHill
3.0%
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
6. Alexander Wales
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
7. Alicorn
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
8. Crimson Square
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
9. Kappa
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
10. lintamande
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
11. nostalgebraist
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
12. Scott Alexander
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
13. Wildbow
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
14. Xamusel
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
0.2%
As you can see, if the author of The Erogamer is one of the 14 authors listed above, then the model’s median probability across the five MFW settings is 94.7% for DaystarEld and 1.3% for Yudkowsky. It seems open and shut: Yudkowsky did not write The Erogamer . If we’re going to point the finger at anyone, we should point it at DaystarEld.
However, there’s something interesting I noticed. If we look at the other work attributed to Groon the Walker, Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist The Erogamer doesn’t appear among its top five closest works, no matter the MFW setting. Additionally, its closest work across all settings is Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality , written by none other than Eliezer Yudkowsky. Using The Erogamer as Groon the Walker’s comparison text and a uniform prior over 15 candidate authors, the model’s median probability across the five MFW settings is 95.0% for Yudkowsky and 0.17% for Groon the Walker the same author as The Erogamer .
In summary, my conclusion after this analysis is that Yudkowsky did not write The Erogamer . But he’s probably the author behind the other work attributed to Groon the Walker: Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist .
Note: The above probabilities are upper bounds because they assume the author of the work I’m investigating is in our candidate set. So, if you think the true author is someone I haven’t considered, you can contact me and give me the author’s name, as well as the works you want me to analyze.
Appendix
Stylometry Process
I first extracted word tokens, defined as maximal sequences of Unicode letters, converted to lowercase. Internal apostrophes were retained so that contractions could remain whole tokens, and the various Unicode apostrophe characters were normalized to the ASCII apostrophe ('). Hyphens and other punctuation terminate tokens. Numeric strings and lexical runs containing numbers were discarded. URLs, markup, embeds, site chrome, reader comments, author notes, polls, and similar non-fiction material were removed where identifiable.
A predefined list of personal pronouns (e.g., i'm, you've, and they'll) was excluded. This was intended to reduce the extent to which the analysis distinguishes first-person from third-person narration rather than authorship.
The primary analysis was restricted to works containing more than 5,000 cleaned tokens. For token $t$ in work $w$, its relative frequency was defined as
\[f_{w,t}=
\frac{\operatorname{count}(t\text{ in }w)}
{\operatorname{total tokens in }w}.\]
To rank candidate features, I first calculated each author’s mean relative frequency:
\[f_{a,t}=
\frac{1}{n_a}\sum_{w\in a}f_{w,t},\]
where $n_a$ is the number of eligible works by author $a$. I then averaged these author-level frequencies:
\[\bar f_t=
\frac{1}{A}\sum_a f_{a,t}.\]
Tokens were ranked by $\bar f_t$, so every author received equal weight. Within an author, every work received equal weight regardless of length.
Before selecting features, tokens were discarded if either their work dominance or author dominance exceeded 50%. Work dominance was defined as
\[D_t^{(\mathrm{work})}=
\frac{\max_w f_{w,t}}
{\sum_w f_{w,t}},\]
and author dominance as
\[D_t^{(\mathrm{author})}=
\frac{\max_a f_{a,t}}
{\sum_a f_{a,t}}.\]
Separate analyses used the highest-ranked 100, 150, 200, 250, and 300 surviving tokens. For a particular feature set, each work initially had a relative-frequency vector
\[\mathbf{x}_w=
[f_{w,t_1},f_{w,t_2},\ldots,f_{w,t_m}].\]
For each token, relative frequencies were z-scored across eligible works using the population standard deviation. The resulting values were ternarized using the standard-normal tertile cutoff (c=\Phi^{-1}(2/3)\approx0.4307):
\[q_{w,t}=
\begin{cases}
-1,&z_{w,t}<-c,\\
0,&-c\le z_{w,t}\le c,\\
+1,&z_{w,t}>c.
\end{cases}\]
Similarity was then measured using cosine distance between the resulting ternary vectors:
\[d(\mathbf q_i,\mathbf q_j)=
1-\frac{\mathbf q_i\cdot\mathbf q_j}
{\lVert\mathbf q_i\rVert\lVert\mathbf q_j\rVert}.\]
Known-Author Checks
The expandable tables below display the nearest neighbors of various works, with bolded cells marking reciprocal top-five neighbors. Identification counts, across MFW settings, whether another work by the same author is ranked first; Short-List counts whether another work by the same author is ranked in the top five. Author-level scores sum each work’s success rate across MFW settings, so every work contributes at most 1 point.
lintamande (28 works; Identification: 27/28, Short-List: 28/28)
leave of absence (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone 2 lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice 3 lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby 4 lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, your obedient servant 5 lintamande, Planecrash / Project Lawful (lintamande-attributed turns) lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, don't touch me
interplanar studies (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, applied theology lintamande, applied theology lintamande, applied theology lintamande, applied theology lintamande, applied theology 2 lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, The Eighth Day 3 lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, spear of ice 4 lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, don't touch me 5 lintamande, you know what they say about the young lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, you know what they say about the young lintamande, you know what they say about the young lintamande, high-energy physics
halls of stone (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice 2 lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This 3 lintamande, leave of absence lintamande, leave of absence lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, leave of absence 4 lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, leave of absence lintamande, leave of absence lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby 5 lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, don't touch me
don't touch me (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby 2 lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, halls of stone 3 lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, fire and ice 4 lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, spear of ice 5 lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, interplanar studies
applied theology (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, interplanar studies 2 lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, The Eighth Day 3 lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This 4 lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, Room of Requirement 5 lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, spear of ice
high-energy physics (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, you know what they say about the young lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement 2 lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, applied theology lintamande, The Eighth Day 3 lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, you know what they say about the young lintamande, applied theology lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, applied theology 4 lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, mommy fix it 5 lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, fire and ice
spear of ice (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone 2 lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This 3 lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby 4 lintamande, your obedient servant lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows 5 lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, leave of absence
galaxy of stars (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice 2 lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, The Giving Trees 3 Kappa, shaker, meet stranger lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty 4 lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, halls of stone 5 lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, fire and ice
I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone 2 lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice 3 lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows 4 lintamande, I know you lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, mommy fix it 5 lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, I know you lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, I know you
the stork drops, the snake swallows (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, spear of ice 2 lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This 3 lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, Room of Requirement 4 lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, fire and ice 5 lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone
the nick of time (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, I know you lintamande, I know you lintamande, I know you lintamande, applied theology lintamande, applied theology 2 lintamande, applied theology lintamande, applied theology lintamande, applied theology lintamande, I know you lintamande, spear of ice 3 lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This 4 lintamande, qualifications lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, halls of stone 5 lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I know you
fire and ice (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby 2 lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty 3 lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This 4 lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows 5 lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, The Giving Trees
twilight of the idols, baby (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, spear of ice 2 lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, halls of stone 3 lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, fire and ice 4 lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty 5 lintamande, Planecrash / Project Lawful (lintamande-attributed turns) lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, we suffer greatly
mommy fix it (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement 2 lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This 3 lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, high-energy physics 4 lintamande, I know you lintamande, I know you lintamande, I know you lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, I know you 5 lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, I know you lintamande, The Eighth Day
we suffer greatly (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby 2 lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, halls of stone 3 lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty 4 lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, spear of ice 5 lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, fire and ice
The Eighth Day (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, applied theology lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, interplanar studies 2 lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, applied theology lintamande, applied theology lintamande, applied theology 3 lintamande, you know what they say about the young lintamande, you know what they say about the young lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, high-energy physics 4 lintamande, applied theology lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, you know what they say about the young lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, The Giving Trees 5 lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, mommy fix it
qualifications (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice 2 lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows 3 lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, halls of stone 4 lintamande, applied theology lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, Room of Requirement 5 lintamande, the nick of time lintamande, applied theology lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, The Eighth Day
you know what they say about the young (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, The Eighth Day 2 lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, interplanar studies 3 lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, The Giving Trees 4 lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, Room of Requirement 5 lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, high-energy physics
it gazed back into me (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, The Giving Trees 2 lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Planecrash / Project Lawful (lintamande-attributed turns) lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement 3 lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, mommy fix it 4 lintamande, I know you lintamande, I know you lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This 5 lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, Planecrash / Project Lawful (lintamande-attributed turns) lintamande, Planecrash / Project Lawful (lintamande-attributed turns)
Let Me Tell You What I Wish I'd Known (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, your obedient servant lintamande, your obedient servant lintamande, your obedient servant lintamande, your obedient servant lintamande, your obedient servant 2 lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This 3 lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, halls of stone 4 lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, leave of absence 5 lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, leave of absence lintamande, spear of ice
I know you (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, The Giving Trees 2 lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This 3 lintamande, applied theology lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, mommy fix it 4 lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement 5 lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows
cry for cancellation (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, halls of stone 2 lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, Room of Requirement 3 lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This 4 lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty 5 lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, your obedient servant lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows
prices or bindings (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby 2 lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement 3 lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty lintamande, The Giving Trees 4 lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, fire and ice 5 lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty
The Giving Trees (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, I know you lintamande, I know you lintamande, I know you lintamande, I know you 2 lintamande, applied theology lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, fire and ice 3 lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This 4 lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, Room of Requirement 5 lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, your obedient servant lintamande, applied theology
overwhelm them with honesty (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement 2 lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, fire and ice 3 lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby 4 lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice 5 lintamande, you know what they say about the young lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, don't touch me lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, The Giving Trees
your obedient servant (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, Let Me Tell You What I Wish I'd Known lintamande, Let Me Tell You What I Wish I'd Known lintamande, Let Me Tell You What I Wish I'd Known lintamande, Let Me Tell You What I Wish I'd Known lintamande, Let Me Tell You What I Wish I'd Known 2 lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This 3 lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, spear of ice 4 lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, halls of stone 5 lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby
Room of Requirement (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, mommy fix it 2 lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty 3 lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, high-energy physics 4 lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows 5 lintamande, Planecrash / Project Lawful (lintamande-attributed turns) lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, spear of ice
Planecrash / Project Lawful (lintamande-attributed turns) (Identification: 0/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Eliezer Yudkowsky, Planecrash / Project Lawful (Eliezer-attributed turns) Eliezer Yudkowsky, Planecrash / Project Lawful (Eliezer-attributed turns) Eliezer Yudkowsky, Planecrash / Project Lawful (Eliezer-attributed turns) Eliezer Yudkowsky, Planecrash / Project Lawful (Eliezer-attributed turns) Eliezer Yudkowsky, Planecrash / Project Lawful (Eliezer-attributed turns) 2 lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement 3 lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, spear of ice 4 lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone 5 lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, spear of ice lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This
Alicorn (14 works; Identification: 13/14, Short-List: 14/14)
Luminosity (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Radiance 2 Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Flashes 3 Wildbow, Worm Wildbow, Worm Wertifloke, The Waves Arisen Groon the Walker, Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist Alicorn, Water 4 Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man BeaconHill, I am Skitter Alicorn, Water Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man 5 Alicorn, Chaser 6 Alicorn, Water Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Groon the Walker, Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist
Radiance (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Luminosity 2 Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Flashes 3 Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Water 4 Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Hubward 5 Alicorn, Sendaway Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Rings
Flashes (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Luminosity 2 Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Radiance 3 Wildbow, Worm Alicorn, Sendaway Alicorn, Sendaway Alicorn, Sendaway Alicorn, Sendaway 4 Wildbow, Ward Wildbow, Worm Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Alicorn, Water 5 Alicorn, Water Groon the Walker, Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality
Double, Double (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Mana 2 Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Muse Alicorn, Mana Alicorn, Mana Alicorn, Hubward 3 Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Muse Alicorn, Muse Alicorn, Muse 4 lintamande, mommy fix it Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Water 5 lintamande, applied theology Alicorn, Mana Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Radiance
Hubward (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Changeling 2 Alicorn, Double, Double Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Radiance 3 Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Double, Double Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Luminosity 4 Alicorn, Sendaway Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Water 5 Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Rings
Water (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alicorn, Mana Alicorn, Mana Alicorn, Mana Alicorn, Mana Alicorn, Mana 2 Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Luminosity 3 Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Muse 4 Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Flashes 5 Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Muse Alicorn, Radiance
Muse (Identification: 3/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Wildbow, Worm Wildbow, Worm Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Water 2 Alicorn, Water Wildbow, Ward Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Luminosity 3 Wildbow, Ward Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Radiance 4 Alicorn, Flashes Wildbow, Pale Wildbow, Worm Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Changeling 5 Wildbow, Pale Alicorn, Rings Wildbow, Ward Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Flashes
Sendaway (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Flashes 2 Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Hubward Wildbow, Worm Wildbow, Worm Alicorn, Luminosity 3 Alicorn, Radiance Wildbow, Worm Alexander Wales, Contratto Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics 4 Wildbow, Worm Alicorn, Water Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Alicorn, Water 5 Alicorn, Water Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Wildbow, Worm
Changeling (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alicorn, Mana Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Rings 2 Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Mana Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Mana Alicorn, Water 3 BeaconHill, I am Skitter Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Mana Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Mana 4 Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Hubward 5 Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Flashes
Rings (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alicorn, Mana Alicorn, Mana Alicorn, Mana Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Mana 2 Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Mana Alicorn, Changeling 3 BeaconHill, I am Skitter Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Flashes 4 Alicorn, Changeling BeaconHill, I am Skitter Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Luminosity 5 Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Muse Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Radiance
Mana (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Water 2 Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Rings 3 Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Changeling 4 BeaconHill, I am Skitter BeaconHill, I am Skitter Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Hubward 5 Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Hubward Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Double, Double
Starwink (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Ibyabek Alicorn, Ibyabek Alicorn, Ibyabek Alicorn, Chaser 6 2 Alicorn, Ibyabek Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Chaser 6 Alicorn, Chaser 6 Alicorn, Ibyabek 3 Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Wertifloke, The Waves Arisen Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Luminosity 4 Wildbow, Worm Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alicorn, Water lintamande, the nick of time qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division 5 Wertifloke, The Waves Arisen Crimson Square, Learning to be Human Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Crimson Square, Learning to be Human Alicorn, Sendaway
Chaser 6 (Identification: 2/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alexander Wales, Upsides Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Wertifloke, The Waves Arisen Alicorn, Ibyabek Alicorn, Ibyabek 2 Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Luminosity Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics 3 Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Wertifloke, The Waves Arisen Alicorn, Luminosity Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle 4 Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Alicorn, Ibyabek Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Luminosity 5 Wildbow, Ward Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Muse
Ibyabek (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Flashes 2 Alicorn, Radiance Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Water Alicorn, Luminosity 3 Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Chaser 6 4 Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Radiance Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Water 5 Alicorn, Sendaway Alicorn, Rings Alicorn, Chaser 6 Alicorn, Chaser 6 Alicorn, Changeling
Alexander Wales (12 works; Identification: 12/12, Short-List: 12/12)
Branches on the Tree of Time (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man 2 Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight 3 Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk 4 Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Wildbow, Worm 5 Wildbow, Worm Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Wildbow, Worm Alexander Wales, Glimwarden
The Last Christmas (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, A Bluer Shade of White Alexander Wales, A Bluer Shade of White Alexander Wales, A Bluer Shade of White Alexander Wales, A Bluer Shade of White 2 Alexander Wales, A Bluer Shade of White Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Contratto 3 Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Iceman, Friendship is Optimal 4 Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man 5 Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Iceman, Friendship is Optimal Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk
The Metropolitan Man (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk 2 Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden 3 Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight 4 Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle 5 Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Contratto
Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Zombie (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk 2 Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man 3 Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle 4 Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, The Last Christmas Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality 5 Alexander Wales, The Last Christmas Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, Transporter Tribulations
Transporter Tribulations (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man 2 Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle 3 Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time 4 Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Zombie 5 Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, Contratto
The Dark Wizard of Donkerk (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight 2 Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden 3 Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man 4 Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle 5 Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Contratto
Shadows of the Limelight (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk 2 Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden 3 Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man 4 Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, Contratto 5 Alexander Wales, Upsides Alexander Wales, Upsides Alexander Wales, A Bluer Shade of White Alexander Wales, A Bluer Shade of White Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle
Upsides (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden 2 Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight 3 Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man 4 Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, Contratto 5 Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle
Glimwarden (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk 2 Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight 3 Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man 4 Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Contratto 5 Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle
Contratto (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight 2 Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, Glimwarden 3 Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk 4 Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man 5 Alexander Wales, Upsides Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Upsides Alexander Wales, A Bluer Shade of White Alexander Wales, A Bluer Shade of White
A Bluer Shade of White (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk 2 Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight 3 Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man 4 Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden 5 Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Contratto
Worth the Candle (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk 2 Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man 3 Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Glimwarden 4 Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight 5 Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Contratto Wildbow, Ward
Eliezer Yudkowsky (5 works; Identification: 3.4/5, Short-List: 3.8/5)
Three Worlds Collide (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality 2 Alexander Wales, Contratto DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix Anderein, El-Ahrairah Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight 3 DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix Anderein, El-Ahrairah Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix Scott Alexander, Unsong 4 Anderein, El-Ahrairah Scott Alexander, Unsong DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix Anderein, El-Ahrairah Anderein, El-Ahrairah 5 Scott Alexander, Unsong Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, Unsong DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix
The Finale of the Ultimate Meta Mega Crossover (Identification: 2/5, Short-List: 4/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality 2 Scott Alexander, Unsong Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics 3 DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, Unsong 4 Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, Unsong DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time 5 Alexander Wales, Contratto Wildbow, Worm Wildbow, Worm Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle
Trust in God, or, The Riddle of Kyon (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality 2 Groon the Walker, Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix Iceman, Friendship is Optimal Groon the Walker, Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix 3 DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix Groon the Walker, Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist Groon the Walker, Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist Iceman, Friendship is Optimal Iceman, Friendship is Optimal 4 Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Iceman, Friendship is Optimal DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix Groon the Walker, Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist 5 Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, Unsong Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide
Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide 2 DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix Eliezer Yudkowsky, Trust in God, or, The Riddle of Kyon DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix 3 Scott Alexander, Unsong Groon the Walker, Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix Eliezer Yudkowsky, Trust in God, or, The Riddle of Kyon Eliezer Yudkowsky, Trust in God, or, The Riddle of Kyon 4 Eliezer Yudkowsky, Trust in God, or, The Riddle of Kyon Eliezer Yudkowsky, Trust in God, or, The Riddle of Kyon Scott Alexander, Unsong Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk 5 Groon the Walker, Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist Scott Alexander, Unsong Groon the Walker, Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, Unsong
Planecrash / Project Lawful (Eliezer-attributed turns) (Identification: 0/5, Short-List: 0/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 lintamande, Planecrash / Project Lawful (lintamande-attributed turns) lintamande, Planecrash / Project Lawful (lintamande-attributed turns) lintamande, Planecrash / Project Lawful (lintamande-attributed turns) lintamande, Planecrash / Project Lawful (lintamande-attributed turns) lintamande, Planecrash / Project Lawful (lintamande-attributed turns) 2 lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone 3 lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby 4 lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, mommy fix it lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This lintamande, leave of absence 5 lintamande, leave of absence lintamande, leave of absence lintamande, leave of absence lintamande, your obedient servant lintamande, spear of ice
Scott Alexander (5 works; Identification: 3.8/5, Short-List: 4.4/5)
The Study of Anglophysics (Identification: 4/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, Unsong 2 Eliezer Yudkowsky, The Finale of the Ultimate Meta Mega Crossover DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix Eliezer Yudkowsky, The Finale of the Ultimate Meta Mega Crossover Wildbow, Worm Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man 3 Scott Alexander, Unsong Eliezer Yudkowsky, The Finale of the Ultimate Meta Mega Crossover Wildbow, Worm Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Eliezer Yudkowsky, The Finale of the Ultimate Meta Mega Crossover 4 Alexander Wales, Contratto Wildbow, Worm Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Wildbow, Worm 5 Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Contratto Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Eliezer Yudkowsky, The Finale of the Ultimate Meta Mega Crossover Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time
…And I Show You How Deep The Rabbit Hole Goes (Identification: 0/5, Short-List: 2/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere 2 qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra nostalgebraist, Floornight qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure nostalgebraist, Floornight 3 qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure 4 Scott Alexander, A Modern Myth qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra 5 qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division Scott Alexander, Unsong qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division
It Was You Who Made My Blue Eyes Blue (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Scott Alexander, A Modern Myth Scott Alexander, A Modern Myth Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, A Modern Myth Scott Alexander, Unsong 2 Anderein, El-Ahrairah Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, A Modern Myth Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, A Modern Myth 3 Scott Alexander, Unsong Alicorn, Mana Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide Alicorn, Hubward Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide 4 Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Alicorn, Hubward Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Alicorn, Mana Xamusel, Magical Girl Lyrical Sayane [Nanoha Quest] 5 Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Mana Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide Alicorn, Mana
Unsong (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics 2 DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere 3 Eliezer Yudkowsky, The Finale of the Ultimate Meta Mega Crossover nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Floornight qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division 4 qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality 5 Scott Alexander, A Modern Myth Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division Scott Alexander, A Modern Myth nostalgebraist, Floornight
A Modern Myth (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, Unsong 2 Eliezer Yudkowsky, The Finale of the Ultimate Meta Mega Crossover Eliezer Yudkowsky, The Finale of the Ultimate Meta Mega Crossover DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix Scott Alexander, It Was You Who Made My Blue Eyes Blue Scott Alexander, It Was You Who Made My Blue Eyes Blue 3 DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix Scott Alexander, It Was You Who Made My Blue Eyes Blue Alicorn, Rings Scott Alexander, …And I Show You How Deep The Rabbit Hole Goes 4 Scott Alexander, It Was You Who Made My Blue Eyes Blue Scott Alexander, It Was You Who Made My Blue Eyes Blue Alicorn, Rings Scott Alexander, …And I Show You How Deep The Rabbit Hole Goes Wildbow, Pale 5 Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Scott Alexander, …And I Show You How Deep The Rabbit Hole Goes Scott Alexander, …And I Show You How Deep The Rabbit Hole Goes Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Alicorn, Rings
DaystarEld (4 works; Identification: 2.4/4, Short-List: 3/4)
HPMOR Remix (Identification: 0/5, Short-List: 0/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality 2 Iceman, Friendship is Optimal Scott Alexander, Unsong Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk 3 Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man 4 Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Iceman, Friendship is Optimal Scott Alexander, Unsong Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide Alexander Wales, Glimwarden 5 Eliezer Yudkowsky, The Finale of the Ultimate Meta Mega Crossover Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Scott Alexander, Unsong Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight
Guardian (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species 2 Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] 3 qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin 4 BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin BeaconHill, Shapes BeaconHill, Shapes BeaconHill, Shapes Thearia, Storm Sage 5 Thearia, Storm Sage Groon the Walker, The Erogamer Thearia, Storm Sage Thearia, Storm Sage BeaconHill, Shapes
Pokemon: The Origin of Species (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 DaystarEld, Guardian DaystarEld, Guardian DaystarEld, Guardian DaystarEld, Guardian DaystarEld, Guardian 2 Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] 3 qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra DaystarEld, Hearts and Minds DaystarEld, Hearts and Minds qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra 4 BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin Groon the Walker, The Erogamer Groon the Walker, The Erogamer qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra Thearia, Storm Sage 5 qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra Thearia, Storm Sage Groon the Walker, The Erogamer
Hearts and Minds (Identification: 2/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 OverReactionGuy, Taylor Hebert's Quest for the Happy Ending [Worm Quest] BeaconHill, Shapes DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species 2 Alicorn, Radiance Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] 3 DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species BeaconHill, Shapes BeaconHill, Shapes BeaconHill, Shapes 4 BeaconHill, Shapes DaystarEld, Guardian DaystarEld, Guardian DaystarEld, Guardian DaystarEld, Guardian 5 Groon the Walker, The Erogamer Alicorn, Radiance OverReactionGuy, Taylor Hebert's Quest for the Happy Ending [Worm Quest] OverReactionGuy, Taylor Hebert's Quest for the Happy Ending [Worm Quest] lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty
Kappa (4 works; Identification: 3.4/4, Short-List: 3.6/4)
shaker, meet stranger (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Kappa, hazmats Kappa, hazmats Kappa, hazmats Kappa, hazmats Kappa, hazmats 2 Kappa, you know what they say about the young lintamande, you know what they say about the young lintamande, Planecrash / Project Lawful (lintamande-attributed turns) lintamande, Planecrash / Project Lawful (lintamande-attributed turns) lintamande, Planecrash / Project Lawful (lintamande-attributed turns) 3 lintamande, you know what they say about the young Kappa, you know what they say about the young lintamande, interplanar studies Kappa, you know what they say about the young Kappa, you know what they say about the young 4 lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, Planecrash / Project Lawful (lintamande-attributed turns) lintamande, The Giving Trees lintamande, you know what they say about the young lintamande, you know what they say about the young 5 Kappa, they broke the mold lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, The Eighth Day
hazmats (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Kappa, shaker, meet stranger Kappa, shaker, meet stranger Kappa, shaker, meet stranger Kappa, shaker, meet stranger Kappa, shaker, meet stranger 2 Kappa, you know what they say about the young lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, Room of Requirement 3 lintamande, you know what they say about the young lintamande, Room of Requirement lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, halls of stone 4 lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, you know what they say about the young lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, I Asked The World For Elsewhere But I Never Imagined This 5 lintamande, the stork drops, the snake swallows lintamande, halls of stone lintamande, halls of stone Kappa, you know what they say about the young lintamande, your obedient servant
you know what they say about the young (Identification: 2/5, Short-List: 3/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Kappa, shaker, meet stranger Kappa, shaker, meet stranger lintamande, applied theology lintamande, you know what they say about the young lintamande, interplanar studies 2 lintamande, you know what they say about the young lintamande, applied theology lintamande, you know what they say about the young lintamande, applied theology lintamande, applied theology 3 lintamande, applied theology lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, The Eighth Day lintamande, The Eighth Day 4 lintamande, high-energy physics lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, you know what they say about the young 5 lintamande, interplanar studies lintamande, you know what they say about the young lintamande, The Eighth Day Kappa, shaker, meet stranger lintamande, high-energy physics
they broke the mold (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Kappa, shaker, meet stranger Kappa, shaker, meet stranger Kappa, shaker, meet stranger Kappa, shaker, meet stranger Kappa, shaker, meet stranger 2 Kappa, hazmats lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, Let Me Tell You What I Wish I'd Known Kappa, hazmats Kappa, hazmats 3 lintamande, galaxy of stars Kappa, hazmats lintamande, you know what they say about the young lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby 4 lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, fire and ice lintamande, twilight of the idols, baby lintamande, you know what they say about the young lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty 5 lintamande, Let Me Tell You What I Wish I'd Known lintamande, you know what they say about the young Kappa, hazmats lintamande, Let Me Tell You What I Wish I'd Known lintamande, you know what they say about the young
qntm (Sam Hughes) (4 works; Identification: 4/4, Short-List: 4/4)
Ed (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure 2 nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra 3 qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere 4 nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight 5 qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division nostalgebraist, Floornight qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division
Fine Structure (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra 2 qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division 3 qntm (Sam Hughes), Ed qntm (Sam Hughes), Ed qntm (Sam Hughes), Ed qntm (Sam Hughes), Ed nostalgebraist, Floornight 4 nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight qntm (Sam Hughes), Ed 5 nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere
Ra (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure 2 qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division 3 qntm (Sam Hughes), Ed qntm (Sam Hughes), Ed nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight 4 nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight qntm (Sam Hughes), Ed qntm (Sam Hughes), Ed nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere 5 nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere qntm (Sam Hughes), Ed
There Is No Antimemetics Division (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra 2 nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure 3 qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight 4 Scott Alexander, Unsong Crimson Square, Reincarnation of an Angel [Worm Quest] Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, Unsong nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere 5 Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Scott Alexander, Unsong nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere Scott Alexander, Unsong
BeaconHill (3 works; Identification: 2/3, Short-List: 2.6/3)
I am Skitter (Identification: 0/5, Short-List: 3/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Wildbow, Ward Wildbow, Worm Alicorn, Luminosity Wildbow, Worm Wildbow, Ward 2 Alicorn, Rings Wildbow, Ward Wildbow, Ward Alicorn, Luminosity Wildbow, Worm 3 Alicorn, Changeling Alicorn, Rings Wildbow, Worm Wildbow, Ward Alicorn, Luminosity 4 BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin Alicorn, Luminosity BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin Crimson Square, The Vonnegut Children 5 Wildbow, Worm Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Rings Wertifloke, The Waves Arisen Wildbow, Pale
Shapes (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin 2 Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] DaystarEld, Guardian DaystarEld, Guardian 3 DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species DaystarEld, Hearts and Minds DaystarEld, Hearts and Minds Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] 4 qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra DaystarEld, Guardian DaystarEld, Guardian qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra 5 qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species BeaconHill, I am Skitter DaystarEld, Hearts and Minds DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species
Shedding Lionskin (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 BeaconHill, Shapes BeaconHill, Shapes BeaconHill, Shapes BeaconHill, Shapes BeaconHill, Shapes 2 Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] 3 BeaconHill, I am Skitter DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species BeaconHill, I am Skitter DaystarEld, Guardian DaystarEld, Guardian 4 DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species BeaconHill, I am Skitter DaystarEld, Guardian DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species BeaconHill, I am Skitter 5 DaystarEld, Guardian DaystarEld, Guardian DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species BeaconHill, I am Skitter DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species
Crimson Square (3 works; Identification: 2/3, Short-List: 2/3)
Learning to be Human (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Crimson Square, The Vonnegut Children Crimson Square, The Vonnegut Children Crimson Square, The Vonnegut Children Crimson Square, The Vonnegut Children Crimson Square, The Vonnegut Children 2 BeaconHill, I am Skitter Wertifloke, The Waves Arisen Alicorn, Luminosity Eliezer Yudkowsky, The Finale of the Ultimate Meta Mega Crossover Alicorn, Luminosity 3 Xamusel, Zeroes and Ones 2.5 [NSFW RPG] Alicorn, Luminosity Wertifloke, The Waves Arisen Alicorn, Luminosity BeaconHill, I am Skitter 4 Wertifloke, The Waves Arisen Xamusel, Zeroes and Ones 2.5 [NSFW RPG] Eliezer Yudkowsky, The Finale of the Ultimate Meta Mega Crossover Wertifloke, The Waves Arisen Eliezer Yudkowsky, The Finale of the Ultimate Meta Mega Crossover 5 Groon the Walker, Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist BeaconHill, I am Skitter BeaconHill, I am Skitter BeaconHill, I am Skitter Wertifloke, The Waves Arisen
Reincarnation of an Angel [Worm Quest] (Identification: 0/5, Short-List: 0/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division Thearia, Storm Sage Thearia, Storm Sage 2 nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight Thearia, Storm Sage qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division 3 Thearia, Storm Sage Thearia, Storm Sage nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight 4 Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] qntm (Sam Hughes), Ed qntm (Sam Hughes), Ed Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] 5 Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics DaystarEld, Guardian qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra DaystarEld, Guardian Eliezer Yudkowsky, Planecrash / Project Lawful (Eliezer-attributed turns)
The Vonnegut Children (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Crimson Square, Learning to be Human Crimson Square, Learning to be Human Crimson Square, Learning to be Human Crimson Square, Learning to be Human Crimson Square, Learning to be Human 2 Eliezer Yudkowsky, The Finale of the Ultimate Meta Mega Crossover BeaconHill, I am Skitter BeaconHill, I am Skitter BeaconHill, I am Skitter BeaconHill, I am Skitter 3 BeaconHill, I am Skitter Eliezer Yudkowsky, The Finale of the Ultimate Meta Mega Crossover Eliezer Yudkowsky, The Finale of the Ultimate Meta Mega Crossover Eliezer Yudkowsky, The Finale of the Ultimate Meta Mega Crossover Alicorn, Luminosity 4 Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Chaser 6 Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Luminosity Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics 5 Alicorn, Sendaway Alicorn, Sendaway Alicorn, Flashes Wertifloke, The Waves Arisen Wildbow, Ward
nostalgebraist (3 works; Identification: 2.6/3, Short-List: 3/3)
Floornight (Identification: 4/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere 2 qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division nostalgebraist, The Northern Caves qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra 3 qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, Unsong qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division 4 nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, The Northern Caves qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra nostalgebraist, The Northern Caves nostalgebraist, The Northern Caves 5 nostalgebraist, The Northern Caves qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure Scott Alexander, Unsong
The Northern Caves (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight 2 nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere nostalgebraist, Almost Nowhere 3 qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, Unsong Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide 4 qntm (Sam Hughes), Ed qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, Unsong 5 Scott Alexander, Unsong Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division
Almost Nowhere (Identification: 4/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 qntm (Sam Hughes), Ed nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight nostalgebraist, Floornight 2 nostalgebraist, Floornight Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, Unsong 3 qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure nostalgebraist, The Northern Caves nostalgebraist, The Northern Caves nostalgebraist, The Northern Caves qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division 4 qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division Scott Alexander, …And I Show You How Deep The Rabbit Hole Goes qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra 5 qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra nostalgebraist, The Northern Caves
Wildbow (3 works; Identification: 3/3, Short-List: 3/3)
Worm (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Wildbow, Ward Wildbow, Ward Wildbow, Ward Wildbow, Ward Wildbow, Ward 2 Wildbow, Pale Wildbow, Pale Wildbow, Pale Wildbow, Pale Wildbow, Pale 3 Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight 4 Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Alicorn, Luminosity Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time 5 Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alicorn, Flashes Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man
Ward (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Wildbow, Pale Wildbow, Pale Wildbow, Pale Wildbow, Pale Wildbow, Pale 2 Wildbow, Worm Wildbow, Worm Wildbow, Worm Wildbow, Worm Wildbow, Worm 3 Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Alicorn, Flashes Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle 4 Alicorn, Flashes Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time 5 Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man
Pale (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Wildbow, Ward Wildbow, Ward Wildbow, Ward Wildbow, Ward Wildbow, Ward 2 Wildbow, Worm Wildbow, Worm Wildbow, Worm Wildbow, Worm Wildbow, Worm 3 Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle 4 Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time 5 Groon the Walker, Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist Alicorn, Muse BeaconHill, I am Skitter Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics BeaconHill, I am Skitter
Groon the Walker (2 works; Identification: NA, Short-List: NA)
Taylor Hebert, Harem Protagonist (Identification: NA, Short-List: NA)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality 2 Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Flashes Wildbow, Worm Alicorn, Luminosity Alicorn, Luminosity 3 Wildbow, Worm Wildbow, Worm Alicorn, Flashes Alicorn, Flashes Wildbow, Ward 4 Wildbow, Ward Eliezer Yudkowsky, The Finale of the Ultimate Meta Mega Crossover Alicorn, Luminosity Wildbow, Worm Wildbow, Worm 5 Wildbow, Pale Wildbow, Ward Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Wildbow, Ward Alicorn, Flashes
Thearia (2 works; Identification: 1.2/2, Short-List: 2/2)
Heaven and Hell [Worm] (Identification: 1/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species Thearia, Storm Sage 2 DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin Thearia, Storm Sage DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species 3 Thearia, Storm Sage Thearia, Storm Sage Thearia, Storm Sage BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin 4 BeaconHill, Shapes DaystarEld, Guardian DaystarEld, Guardian DaystarEld, Guardian DaystarEld, Guardian 5 DaystarEld, Guardian Groon the Walker, The Erogamer DaystarEld, Hearts and Minds DaystarEld, Hearts and Minds DaystarEld, Hearts and Minds
Storm Sage (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] 2 qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division Crimson Square, Reincarnation of an Angel [Worm Quest] Crimson Square, Reincarnation of an Angel [Worm Quest] Crimson Square, Reincarnation of an Angel [Worm Quest] Crimson Square, Reincarnation of an Angel [Worm Quest] 3 Crimson Square, Reincarnation of an Angel [Worm Quest] Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species DaystarEld, Guardian 4 DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division DaystarEld, Guardian DaystarEld, Guardian DaystarEld, Pokemon: The Origin of Species 5 DaystarEld, Guardian DaystarEld, Guardian qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra qntm (Sam Hughes), Ra Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight
Xamusel (2 works; Identification: 2/2, Short-List: 2/2)
Zeroes and Ones 2.5 [NSFW RPG] (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Xamusel, Magical Girl Lyrical Sayane [Nanoha Quest] Xamusel, Magical Girl Lyrical Sayane [Nanoha Quest] Xamusel, Magical Girl Lyrical Sayane [Nanoha Quest] Xamusel, Magical Girl Lyrical Sayane [Nanoha Quest] Xamusel, Magical Girl Lyrical Sayane [Nanoha Quest] 2 Alexander Wales, The Last Christmas Crimson Square, Learning to be Human Wildbow, Pale Iceman, Friendship is Optimal Iceman, Friendship is Optimal 3 Crimson Square, Learning to be Human Wildbow, Pale Iceman, Friendship is Optimal Crimson Square, Learning to be Human Wildbow, Pale 4 qntm (Sam Hughes), Fine Structure Alexander Wales, The Last Christmas Crimson Square, Learning to be Human Alexander Wales, The Last Christmas Scott Alexander, Unsong 5 Wildbow, Pale Iceman, Friendship is Optimal Alexander Wales, The Last Christmas Wildbow, Pale Crimson Square, Learning to be Human
Magical Girl Lyrical Sayane [Nanoha Quest] (Identification: 5/5, Short-List: 5/5)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Xamusel, Zeroes and Ones 2.5 [NSFW RPG] Xamusel, Zeroes and Ones 2.5 [NSFW RPG] Xamusel, Zeroes and Ones 2.5 [NSFW RPG] Xamusel, Zeroes and Ones 2.5 [NSFW RPG] Xamusel, Zeroes and Ones 2.5 [NSFW RPG] 2 OverReactionGuy, Taylor Hebert's Quest for the Happy Ending [Worm Quest] OverReactionGuy, Taylor Hebert's Quest for the Happy Ending [Worm Quest] OverReactionGuy, Taylor Hebert's Quest for the Happy Ending [Worm Quest] Alicorn, Sendaway Alicorn, Sendaway 3 Crimson Square, Learning to be Human Crimson Square, Learning to be Human Alexander Wales, The Last Christmas OverReactionGuy, Taylor Hebert's Quest for the Happy Ending [Worm Quest] Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics 4 Alexander Wales, The Last Christmas Alicorn, Sendaway Alicorn, Sendaway Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics qntm (Sam Hughes), There Is No Antimemetics Division 5 Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Alexander Wales, The Last Christmas Iceman, Friendship is Optimal Iceman, Friendship is Optimal Alexander Wales, The Last Christmas
Anderein (1 work; Identification: NA, Short-List: NA)
El-Ahrairah (Identification: NA, Short-List: NA)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality 2 Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide Wertifloke, The Waves Arisen Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide 3 Wertifloke, The Waves Arisen Wildbow, Worm Wertifloke, The Waves Arisen Eliezer Yudkowsky, Three Worlds Collide Wertifloke, The Waves Arisen 4 Eliezer Yudkowsky, The Finale of the Ultimate Meta Mega Crossover DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix Wildbow, Worm Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight 5 Scott Alexander, Unsong Wertifloke, The Waves Arisen Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk
Iceman (1 work; Identification: NA, Short-List: NA)
Friendship is Optimal (Identification: NA, Short-List: NA)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man 2 Alexander Wales, The Metropolitan Man DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Scott Alexander, Unsong Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality 3 Alexander Wales, Branches on the Tree of Time Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Wildbow, Worm Eliezer Yudkowsky, Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality Scott Alexander, Unsong 4 Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics DaystarEld, HPMOR Remix Wildbow, Worm Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics 5 Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, Unsong Scott Alexander, The Study of Anglophysics Wildbow, Worm
OverReactionGuy (1 work; Identification: NA, Short-List: NA)
Taylor Hebert's Quest for the Happy Ending [Worm Quest] (Identification: NA, Short-List: NA)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 DaystarEld, Hearts and Minds Xamusel, Magical Girl Lyrical Sayane [Nanoha Quest] DaystarEld, Hearts and Minds DaystarEld, Hearts and Minds DaystarEld, Hearts and Minds 2 lintamande, overwhelm them with honesty BeaconHill, I am Skitter Xamusel, Magical Girl Lyrical Sayane [Nanoha Quest] Xamusel, Magical Girl Lyrical Sayane [Nanoha Quest] BeaconHill, Shapes 3 Xamusel, Magical Girl Lyrical Sayane [Nanoha Quest] BeaconHill, Shapes BeaconHill, Shapes Crimson Square, Learning to be Human Xamusel, Magical Girl Lyrical Sayane [Nanoha Quest] 4 Kappa, shaker, meet stranger DaystarEld, Hearts and Minds BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin Thearia, Heaven and Hell [Worm] 5 BeaconHill, Shapes Alicorn, Radiance BeaconHill, I am Skitter BeaconHill, Shapes BeaconHill, Shedding Lionskin
Wertifloke (1 work; Identification: NA, Short-List: NA)
The Waves Arisen (Identification: NA, Short-List: NA)
Rank 100 MFWs 150 MFWs 200 MFWs 250 MFWs 300 MFWs
1 Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alicorn, Luminosity Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight 2 Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Wildbow, Worm Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk 3 Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Alexander Wales, Shadows of the Limelight Alexander Wales, Glimwarden Wildbow, Worm 4 Wildbow, Worm Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Alexander Wales, The Dark Wizard of Donkerk Wildbow, Worm Alexander Wales, Glimwarden 5 Alexander Wales, Contratto Alicorn, Luminosity Wildbow, Worm Anderein, El-Ahrairah Alexander Wales, Worth the Candle
Bayesian Calibration Model
We analyze each MFW setting separately. Each work was paired with each of the 14 candidate authors. For each candidate author $a$, I record:
\[C_a \in \{1, 2\text{–}5, >5\}\]
where $C_a$ is the minimum rank occupied by any work attributed to author $a$. I also record whether author $a$ is the work’s actual author: $z=\text{correct}$ when it is, and $z=\text{incorrect}$ otherwise.
For each source author $s$ (the known author of the work being tested) and status $z \in \lbrace \text{correct}, \text{incorrect} \rbrace$, the model is:
\[\boldsymbol{\mu}_z \sim \operatorname{Dirichlet}(1,1,1)\]
\[\kappa_z \sim \operatorname{LogNormal}(\log 3, 1)\]
\[\boldsymbol{\theta}_{s,z}
\sim
\operatorname{Dirichlet}(\kappa_z \boldsymbol{\mu}_z)\]
\[\mathbf{n}_{s,z}
\sim
\operatorname{Multinomial}(N_{s,z}, \boldsymbol{\theta}_{s,z})\]
where:
$\boldsymbol{\mu}_z$ is the population-level distribution over the three rank categories.
$\kappa_z$ controls how similar the source authors are to one another.
$\boldsymbol{\theta}_{s,z}$ is the source author $s$’s rank-category distribution.
$\mathbf{n}_{s,z}$ contains, for source author $s$, the observed counts in rank 1, ranks 2-5, and ranks >5.
In the actual PyMC implementation, $\boldsymbol{\theta}$ is analytically marginalized, producing a Dirichlet-multinomial likelihood. After sampling the hyperparameters, we can generate conditional posterior draws:
\[\boldsymbol{\theta}_{s,z} \mid \text{data} \sim \operatorname{Dirichlet}\left(\mathbf{n}_{s,z} + \kappa_{z}\boldsymbol{\mu}_z\right)\]
I then average the rank-category distributions equally over the 14 authors:
\[\bar{\boldsymbol{\theta}}_{z} = \frac{1}{14}\sum_s \boldsymbol{\theta}_{s,z}\]
Right now, we’re able to estimate $P(C = c \mid \text{correct})$ and $P(C = c \mid \text{incorrect})$, but we want to be able to estimate $P(\text{correct} \mid C = c)$. For this, we need the power of Bayes. We’ll apply the principle of indifference and assume each author is equally likely, that is, $P(\text{correct}) = \frac{1}{14}$ and $P(\text{incorrect}) = \frac{13}{14}$. Bayes’ rule tells us:
\[P(\text{correct} | C = c) = \frac{P(C = c \mid \text{correct})}{P(C = c \mid \text{correct}) + 13P(C = c \mid \text{incorrect})}\]
